jump to navigation

NOTE: The spam filter is being unusually aggressive. If you comment does not immediately appear, it has simply been placed in moderation and I will approve it as quickly as possible. Thank you for your patience.

"Murphy was an optimist!"

Where the Hell is West Knoxville?! November 15, 2009 9:28 pm

Posted by Doug McCaughan in : Daily Life
, trackback

Our professional journalists don’t know our city. Our newspaper is guilty. All the television stations are guilty. Our "professional" online news outlets, WATE, WBIR, etc. are guilty. WBIR is by far the worst offender. Each of these professional journalism businesses purport "West Knoxville" to be random places that are not downtown or South Knoxville.

Knoxville has a bad case of poor urban planning and sprawl. If you look at Knoxville with a critical eye, and I mean go back and look at the trolley maps, and pay attention to the way schools were laid out, our city’s earlier developers had to believe Knoxville was going to sprawl north. But the people north of Knoxville did not sell their farms. Instead, the people to the west of Knoxville sold and development, and money, built toward the setting sun. Somewhere along the way, some silly "us versus them" started between the westies and the downtownies which continues to this day. Anyone living west is painted as unfairly privileged by the rest of Knoxville; and anyone not west is painted as..well.."not west" but generally downtownies. I believe our news agencies stoke the fires of this west versus everyone else problem. So where exactly is West Knoxville?! WBIR just ran a story about a robbery in West Knoxville that is a 20 minute drive from where I live in West Knoxville. I usually avoid commenting on our local news sites but had to leave this:

Do you have a map that shows the areas of Knoxville? By WBIR’s reports, "West Knoxville" seems to be everything except Gay Street. This Petro’s is practically in Lenoir City. Seems to me that giving a location like "West Knoxville" is supposed to help the reader put the place into their mind but how can we do that when one news report has West Knoxville just North of Alcoa Hwy, another puts West Knoxville at the intersection of Old Kingston Pike and Kingston Pike, another puts West Knoxville in Bearden…West Town Mall..Farragut.

For clarity sake, shouldn’t "West Knoxville" be a little more specific? Heading West on Kingston Pike from Downtown perhaps we need: Downtown -> Campus -> Sequoyah -> Homberg -> Bearden -> West Town -> West Knoxville -> Farragut -> Dixie Lee Junction. Seems to me those are the names that come up in face to face conversations to identify "West Knoxville" specifically.

I’ll start collecting a list of West Knoxville stories and see if we can put together a map.

Update: Here’s a story by Knoxnews where the shootout victims might be in Northwest Knoxville or maybe they are Downtown. See the article’s comments to understand why.

Comments after advertisement

Comments»

1. paula - November 16, 2009

I thought when you bought a house out west a bag of money came with it..imagine my disappointment

2. Meredith - November 16, 2009

They don’t know where East Knoxville is either.

Teh media es stoopid.

3. Doug McCaughan - November 16, 2009

You know when I first looked at a map of Knoxville, I thought it looked like someone was building an Interstate from Nashville to Asheville and when they got to Knoxville declared, “Oh look! There’s a city here!”

4. Morgan - November 16, 2009

I wish I could remember what my historical archaeology professor told me about the original boundaries of the city of Knoxville. Its something like the river, 3rd creek, another creek and maybe some certain railroad lines. I’m not sure but it was a pretty small area compared to today. So that is why I think Alcoa highway or the edge of campus is appropriate as “West,” even if it has spread for miles and miles. Wherever the western most “Welcome to Knoxville” sign is where it ends, lol.

5. Doug McCaughan - November 16, 2009

There’s a Welcome to Knoxville sign just west of my West Knoxville house in Rocky Hill but I’m in the county. Does that make me me just east of West Knoxville? 🙂

It takes me 10-15 minutes to drive from that Welcome to Knoxville sign to get to the Alcoa Highway West Knoxville. It’s all very screwy. I think there is difference between “West of Knoxville” and “West Knoxville”

My point was that the description “West Knoxville” in a news story about a robbery is wasted words. They might as well just call it “A Knoxville Robbery” and save a little ink.


trackback