jump to navigation

NOTE: The spam filter is being unusually aggressive. If you comment does not immediately appear, it has simply been placed in moderation and I will approve it as quickly as possible. Thank you for your patience.

"Murphy was an optimist!"

Michael Moore’s Sicko Review June 30, 2007 12:10 am

Posted by Doug McCaughan in : Daily Life, Health, Of Interest, Touchy Subjects, TV / Movies
, trackback

A really big thank you needs to be extended to R Neal and Mrs. Neal for putting together this opportunity for the blogging community to gather.

US Canada health care comparison

The first thing that hit me was my overwhelming inability to put faces to online personages. (Sorry to anyone that I shoved the camera in your face and took a picture. I was doing what I was told “take closeup pictures” and it only occurred to me later that I could stand back and use the zoom.) Then I was hit with the nostalgia of Downtown 8. Wow! That theatre hasn’t changed in years. The lack of stadium seating and the click-click-click of non-digital projection really took me back.

I have never seen a Michael Moore film so I truly did not know what to expect. I thought this would be a dull documentary. It was a well narrated, well filmed and entertaining story. From all the controversial and negativeness I have heard, I truly expected the film to be terribly lopsided. On the contrary, I found the information well presented and it seemed very fair. Yes, perhaps the "average" family in France did not truly represent an average family but it made its point well. In January (and other times), I have read and looked into alternative ways health care is provided around the world. I am no expert but Sicko’s information seemed to match my reading.

Cathy and I are two of the 50 million uninsured Americans and we suffer because of it. The children are covered by insurance but I live under constant fear that something will happen to us before I can change our insurance situation. I personally connected with this film on several levels. I laughed. I was awed. I nearly cried. The film documented a future I fear for Cathy and myself. MM SickoBut it goes beyond us. As a cash pay in the doctor’s office, I have noted the different ways we are treated. While an insurance company may deny a procedure, cash never gets turned down; however, it gets frowned at and somehow I feel like I end up in the hands of lessor trained doctors while the insured get the cream of the crop.

Before this film came out, I felt that the health care system in America needed a dramatic change. Yes, I favor a more socialized approach. I feel that if we take care of our citizens then our citizens will take much better care of our society and we will be an even better country. I left the theatre in high spirits knowing that I am not alone in my hopes that one day we will put people’s health above profit. Even if you are a Michael Moore hater, I encourage you to see this film!

I almost took a picture of the near full theatre and could kick myself for not doing so after reading Michael Moore’s letter asking for pictures. I did a rough headcount and gather that there were between 80-100 people watching. In attendance (links to reviews/opinions in bold):

Saw the show

Did not see the show

Update: Cnn Analysis of Sicko. "numbers mostly accurate; more context needed"

As we dug deep to uncover the numbers, we found surprisingly few inaccuracies in the film.[emphasis added] In fact, most pundits or health-care experts we spoke to spent more time on errors of omission rather than disputing the actual claims in the film.

As Americans continue to spend $2 trillion a year on health care, everyone agrees on one point: Things need to change, and it will take more than a movie to figure out how to get there.
[Source]

CNN Reviews Sicko

In a nutshell, Moore’s argument comes down to this: the insurance companies are making a killing at their customers’ expense.

Having “enjoyed” first-hand experience of two of these three health systems — the British and the Canadian — I can attest that they’re not quite as idyllic as Mr. Moore paints them. Except in comparison with the U.S. system, of course, and that’s the point.[emphasis added] Moore is a master of overstatement, but his comic shtick hits the target more often than not. It only hurts when we laugh.

With four times as many health lobbyists as there are congressmen, and with multimillion-dollar campaign donations at stake, the prospect of universal care seems a distant hope.

It’s not impossible that this bitterly funny, bitterly sad call to alms could move reform back up the political agenda. For that reason alone, you owe it to yourself to see this movie. [emphasis added]
[Source]

Some doctors are for national health care: Physicians for a Nation Health Program

Update: Slate: Michael Moore and the Beige Bomber
KnoxBlab discussion
More at Knoxviews
Betsy Pickle – KNS reviewer

Comments after advertisement

Comments»

1. Russ McBee - June 30, 2007

Great review. I was there last night, too. I’m still mulling over the film, but I firmly believe it’s one every person in the US should see.

2. Digital Camera News and Reviews » Michael Moore’s Sicko Review - June 30, 2007

[…] A really big thank you needs to be extended to R Neal and Mrs. Neal for putting together this opportunity for the blogging community to gather. The first thing that hit me was my overwhelming inability to put faces to online personages. (Sorry to anyone that I shoved the camera in your face…-digital projection really took me back. I have never seen a Michael Moore film so I truly did… and gather that there were between 80-100 people watching. In attendance (links to reviews in bold):Read more…Tags: […]

3. Tennessee Jed - June 30, 2007

I was there too! Thanks Mr. and Mrs. Neil! That kind of activism is the absolute best thing you could have done.

I did a little post in my common man’s way about the feelings the day Captain America died and watching SiCKO.

4. JGreene - June 30, 2007

By the way, Tennessee Jed is my hubby. He was a bit late joining the pre-movie discussion. You can link to him through my name or list him separately. His blog can be seen at http://tennessee-jed.blogspot.com

JGreene a.k.a MountainGirl

5. Digital Camera News and Reviews » Michael Moore’s Sicko Review - July 1, 2007

[…] Michael Moore’s Sicko Review A really big thank you needs to be extended to R Neal and Mrs. Neal for putting together this opportunity for the blogging community to gather. The first thing that hit me was my overwhelming inability to put faces to online personages. (Sorry to anyone that I shoved the camera in your face and took… […]

6. Reality Me » You don't get what you don't ask for - July 1, 2007

[…] I noticed that another post was stolen yesterday, I decided to follow Lorelle VanFossen’s advice and contact the thief. I posted the following […]

7. Reality Me » From the mouths of babes - July 2, 2007

[…] We saw Sicko Friday night and dragged Tommy and Sarah along (they enjoyed it!). […]


trackback